Navigation

Inconclusive Result

Following the Division 1 League Roundup John Alfred (Captain of Adare A) claimed that the result of Division 1 was inconclusive. At John's request I have removed the text of his actual email which I had quoted here so that his claims were accurately represented.

However as John raised questions about the result of the MCUs main competition and circulated his email to others outside the Committee the issues themselves are still addressed here for the benefit of our members.

John claimed that the result of Division 1 was 'inconclusive' because Adare A and Ennis A finished on equal points. He raised three issues about the result:

1. that the tie-break rules to determine the outcome did not apply.

2. that Ennis had played ineligible players under the guest player rule identifying:

  1. Colm Daly - Dublin
  2. Tony Aherne - Westport
  3. Lorcan O'Toole - Galway

3. that some Ennis players were not registered with the ICU in time.

MCU Response ...

League Pages

  1. 2018 Division 1
  2. Div 1 Schedule
  3. Div 1 Match Results
  4. Div 1 Game Results


  5. Team Contacts
  6. League Rules (pdf)
  7. League Captains Manual (pdf)

2017 Archive

  1. 2017 Division 1
  2. Div 1 Schedule
  3. Div 1 Match Results
  4. Div 1 Game Results

  5. 2017 Division 2
  6. Div 2 Schedule
  7. Div 2 Match Results
  8. Div 2 Game Results

2016 Archive

  1. 2016 Division 1 Review
  2. 2016 Division 1
  3. Div 1 Match Results
  4. Div 1 Game Results
  5. Division 1 Schedule (pdf)

  6. 2016 Division 2 Review
  7. 2016 Division 2
  8. Div 2 Match Results
  9. Div 2 Game Results
  10. Division 2 Schedule (pdf)

2015 Archive

  1. Division 1 Review
  2. Div 1 Match Results
  3. Div 1 Game Results
  4. Division 1 Schedule (pdf)
  5. Division 2 Review
  6. Div 2 Match Results
  7. Div 2 Game Results
  8. Division 2 Schedule (pdf)

2014 Archive

  1. Division 1 Result
  2. Division 2 Result
  3. Division 2 Anomaly
  4. "Inconclusive Result"
  5. MCU Clarification